图书标签: 清史  海外中国研究  历史  西南  殖民  Ethnography  新清史  Cartography   

喜欢 Qing Colonial Enterprise 的读者还喜欢

• 
  From Frontier Policy to Foreign Policy pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  The Sea of Learning pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  New Qing Imperial History pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  A Court on Horseback pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  A World Trimmed with Fur pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Beyond the Pass pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Early Modern China and Northeast Asia pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  The Sichuan Frontier and Tibet pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  China's Last Empire pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载
• 
  Emperor Qianlong pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载

洋博士的水论文，前100页是西方民族志和地图学文献综述，最后20页是苗民文献综述，实际的干货只有中间80页，也没说清楚清朝如何具体地在贵州进行殖民活动，总之轻重不分。

真的是非常unimpressed...ethnography和cartography就算了，重点是老混淆和偷换概念：非要走新清史套路分开讲满清和汉人、族群差异化，就不要时而Qing时而Han的又不解释关系啊，到底是谁殖民？ 史料证据引用我也是服了法国无名氏也能引用……接受不能ugh

an imperial order established during the “seeing and being seen” & cartography as an imperial knowledge production in the colonial eyes & visualizing landscape & Miao Albums: the emergence of a distinct ethnographic genre

真的是非常unimpressed...ethnography和cartography就算了，重点是老混淆和偷换概念：非要走新清史套路分开讲满清和汉人、族群差异化，就不要时而Qing时而Han的又不解释关系啊，到底是谁殖民？ 史料证据引用我也是服了法国无名氏也能引用……接受不能ugh

概念模糊，逻辑混乱，前后不搭，乱塞题目，只为闹个“清也是殖民国”大新闻。开头囫囵吞枣“前现代”概念，其实颇有可挖，尤其前现代反映在帝国时空观的转变（从寰宇普世自我中心变为意识到各民族与政权地域、从无限延展时空到发现有限地域与治下各社群之过去、从天然统摄变为需要强调己方政治统治）而由制图技术显示（清楚表示各政权，用十字线标定地理位置，逐步减少图形与文字表述而只标国名地名，将人文风俗描述转交专门民族志），抓住此点深谈即可，结果树立一个中西/传统现代二分稻草人乱打一顿，民族志、制图两种技术两者关系，其政治与殖民意义全无深入。谈所谓清代在前现代全球位置，不过简单把中西制图技术对比描述一番，毫无创见。谈清代在贵州制图标绘纳入疆域，用民族志划定被殖民人群风俗文化，是好案例但笔法混乱且篇幅不足。

本書最有意思的是導論，作者把清朝政府與同時代歐洲的殖民帝國相提並論，她期期要告訴我們，從近代早期（early modern）觀點來看，中國與歐洲的差異沒那麼大。我們老用近代歐洲的標準，去衡量前近代的中國，才是有問題的。特別是在本書的兩個主題：地圖學與民族誌的發展上，我...  

Although Qing Colonial Enterprise was published before China Marches West, its focus very much overlaps with Part IV of the latter work. This book explores the Qing state’s use of cartographic and ethnographic representation in the building of empire. Th...

Although Qing Colonial Enterprise was published before China Marches West, its focus very much overlaps with Part IV of the latter work. This book explores the Qing state’s use of cartographic and ethnographic representation in the building of empire. Th...

Although Qing Colonial Enterprise was published before China Marches West, its focus very much overlaps with Part IV of the latter work. This book explores the Qing state’s use of cartographic and ethnographic representation in the building of empire. Th...