-->
发表于2024-06-14
The Confucian-Legalist State pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024
In the The Confucian-Legalist State, Dingxin Zhao offers a radically new analysis of Chinese imperial history from the eleventh century BCE to the fall of the Qing dynasty. This study first uncovers the factors that explain how, and why, China developed into a bureaucratic empire under the Qin dynasty in 221 BCE. It then examines the political system that crystallized during the Western Han dynasty, a system that drew on China's philosophical traditions of Confucianism and Legalism. Despite great changes in China's demography, religion, technology, and socioeconomic structures, this Confucian-Legalist political system survived for over two millennia. Yet, it was precisely because of the system's resilience that China, for better or worse, did not develop industrial capitalism as Western Europe did, notwithstanding China's economic prosperity and technological sophistication beginning with the Northern Song dynasty.
In examining the nature of this political system, Zhao offers a new way of viewing Chinese history, one that emphasizes the importance of structural forces and social mechanisms in shaping historical dynamics. As a work of historical sociology, The Confucian-Legalist State aims to show how the patterns of Chinese history were not shaped by any single force, but instead by meaningful activities of social actors which were greatly constrained by, and at the same time reproduced and modified, the constellations of political, economic, military, and ideological forces. This book thus offers a startling new understanding of long-term patterns of Chinese history, one that should trigger debates for years to come among historians, political scientists, and sociologists.
Dingxin Zhao is Professor of Sociology at the University of Chicago and the author of several books, including the award-winning Power of Tiananmen (University of Chicago Press, 2001).
感觉只是把《东周战争》提出的框架用历史细节给补充了而已,仍然是在Tilly和Mann的基础上推进战争在国家的诞生中起的作用。不过这本书赵将重心放在了儒法国家的诞生以及其超稳定结构,从历史学的角度来看没什么新鲜的,但是社会科学重点是要找出分析机制,也是挺无聊的。赵真是在何处都要黑彭慕兰。
评分从赵鼎新本人处证实,该书会由浙江大学出版社出中译本。
评分没有想象中那么好,一流但不是超一流。好话当然可以说很多:宏大历史架构与具体机制操作之间的熟稔勾连,赵本人津津乐道地多因对多果的方法,儒法国家概念本身蕴含的理论概括力和独特的问题意识等。遗憾:过度推论的漏洞仍然没有补上,核心内容没有超越十年前的中文草稿,对曼的理论应用比较机械……
评分目前来看,批评有两点:一个是过于简化的竞争机制,另一个是理想化的社会权力类型。迈克尔曼认为很难给四种社会权力下一个精确的定义并指出运作逻辑,国师给了一套定义,又被劳森指责有以现代观念硬套前现代社会之嫌(比如公-私)。归根结底,这是整体主义方法论和个体主义方法论的矛盾:如果个人相对于社会结构不重要,那么古人能否理解社会学概念工具又有什么关系?正是在这种帕森斯视角下,才有了经济-军事权力偏累积、政治-意识形态权力偏守成的论断,其中经济积累倾向去中心化、军事积累倾向中心化。中国的超稳定结构就是以军事积累塑造帝国疆域(秦),以政治-意识形态权力塑造帝国体制(汉),控制军事权力(文-武)、排斥经济权力(士-商)的结果。框架简洁,矛盾巨多。
评分从赵鼎新本人处证实,该书会由浙江大学出版社出中译本。
【本文节选自《开放时代》2019年第4期】 编者按 赵鼎新的英文近著《儒法国家:中国历史的新理论》(The Confucian-Legalist State:A New Theory of Chinese History)自出版以来,广受国内外学界关注,且于2016年荣获美国社会学学会政治社会学分会年度杰出专著奖。本刊曾于201...
评分之前觉得秦晖很有说服力,扎实、雄辩。然后看到赵鼎新,感觉好像更厉害,因为他有耀眼的理性的光辉,以及,因此而显得货真价实的正能量(这种货真价实在“御用文人”中难得一见)。但秦晖好像也没错,那这是怎么回事,为什么他们的观点如此不同?于是再回过头去把两人看了又看...
评分之前觉得秦晖很有说服力,扎实、雄辩。然后看到赵鼎新,感觉好像更厉害,因为他有耀眼的理性的光辉,以及,因此而显得货真价实的正能量(这种货真价实在“御用文人”中难得一见)。但秦晖好像也没错,那这是怎么回事,为什么他们的观点如此不同?于是再回过头去把两人看了又看...
评分美国学者从进入幼儿园到博士毕业几乎没有接触过中国历史(事实上,典型的美国学生对易洛魁人①的了解比对整个亚洲的了解还要多),这是少有例外的。这种无知导致的一个悲哀的后果便是比较历史社会学家和比较政治学家所构建的理论都不涉及中国。我们的国家形成理论与帝国比较研...
评分非常荣幸能被邀请为这部精彩的著作写一份简短的书评。第一次与该书作者见面时,他还是就读于麦吉尔大学的学生,自那时起,我就对他很是钦佩,而今天他对中华文明特质的阐释工作圆满完成,我为他感到高兴。我在本文中的评论只不过是把作者书中所讲的内容又强调了一遍,原因极为...
The Confucian-Legalist State pdf epub mobi txt 电子书 下载 2024